Earlier this year an American businessman named Russell George had an idea: dump about a hundred tons of iron sulfate into the Pacific Ocean. Why?
He wanted to watch the plankton bloom, of course. it almost sounds like a joke, and yet a lot of people aren’t laughing.
Michael Specter, a writer for the New Yorker, wrote a post that makes George seem like a nutty vigilante willing to endanger the entire planet in his hopes of finding a way to manufacture carbon credits.
Specter wrote:
“George’s unilateral action was deplorable, premature, and violated several international laws and United Nations covenants. (Well, unilateral may be harsh. He apparently convinced the council of an indigenous village to approve the project.)”
Iron sulfate is a kind of fertilizer for plankton, which in turn has a tendency to suck carbon out of the atmosphere and drag it down to the depths of the ocean.
George was testing the hypothesis that by spurring a vast plankton bloom he could hammer a dent in atmospheric carbon. Some people allege that he is doing this purely for economic reasons: removing carbon from the atmosphere could earn him carbon credits he could sell to others. He could, in theory, even trade the credits on markets.
Carbon credit auctions made their debut in California a little less than a month ago, and showed there may be a market for the contracts among some businesses.
Under California’s AB 32, a packet of regulations designed to reduce carbon emissions in the state, companies are allotted a certain number of “credits” equal to a certain number of units of carbon emission. They must remain within these limits; if they fall short of them, they can sell the balance to other companies who may be greater polluters.
While meant to be a way to knit market forces with environmental concerns, the carbon credits program has seemingly opened the door to a new market of businessmen looking to profit from the program by running a negative carbon emissions balance. A company whose sole activity consists of removing carbon from the atmosphere could be eligible for just that.
Enter Russ George. He headed a company called Planktos, Inc. and started another with the Haida people of Canada. It was the Haida with whom he worked on the iron sulfate dump in the Pacific Ocean.
The Haida are what the government of Canada calls a “First People”, an elegant name the Canadians use to describe the peoples who lived on the North American continent before European settlers began arriving.
The Haida took and interest in and ultimately supported George’s project in the hope that the boost in the plankton supply would correspondingly boost the salmon population. Salmon numbers have dwindled from their former abundance along much of the North American coast.
George stated emphatically in an interview with Scientific American that the project is first about the Haida.
Some doubt this assertion and choose to emphasize instead that George violated UN conventions against “geo-engineering”.
An article in the Guardian (UK) by Martin Lukacs, dated October 15, 2012, included this, among other things,
“It appears to be a blatant violation of two international resolutions,” said Kristina M Gjerde, a senior high seas adviser for the International Union for Conservation of Nature. “Even the placement of iron particles into the ocean, whether for carbon sequestration or fish replenishment, should not take place, unless it is assessed and found to be legitimate scientific research without commercial motivation. This does not appear to even have had the guise of legitimate scientific research.”
comments